China’s Mass Brainwashing for the Modern Age

WHO SAID BRAINWASHING in China was passé? The Congressional-Executive Commission on China has compiled a rather frightening little list showing that it is still rather in vogue. At least against anyone who happens to practice Falun Gong, the spiritual discipline.

Documents they have collected–the same ones we reported about six months ago here and here–portray a persecution that is both terrifying and, at least on paper, banal. The key word is "quotas." Everything is metered: "transformation" rates, "recidivism" rates, and even things called "responsibility agreements" that local businesses are forced to sign, so that they will hand over their Falun Gong staff to the government doctors in white coats.

For those who don't know much about this, see the Wikipedia page for as good an introduction as any. Here is the basic table that shows what the new campaign hopes to achieve:

Stage

Selected Themes

Stage 1: 2010

  • Establishing targets for the campaign
  • The signing of "responsibility agreements" to implement "transformation through reeducation"

Stage 2: 2011

  • Training a professional cadre corps and a civil, volunteer "help and education" corps to participate in "transformation" work
  • "Deeply launching the work of a transformation-through-reeducation assault and consolidation"

Stage 3: 2012

  • Developing a long-term mechanism for work to "return to society" Falun Gong practitioners who have renounced their belief in and practice of Falun Gong
  • Drawing lessons from the experience of the campaign and "establish[ing] and perfect[ing] long-lasting mechanisms for transformation through reeducation work"
  • Proposing new "transformation through reeducation" duties

In case it is unclear, "transformation" refers to brainwashing through phsyical and psychological torture. We needn't get into the details here. See the second article above. It's not something you want to happen to anyone you love.

There is much more of interest:

The documents also call for the establishment of mechanisms to place greater responsibility for "transformation" work on actors at the local level, such as governments, Party organizations, businesses, and individuals.

This seems to recall the Party's general strategy for "outsourcing" censorship over the last few years. It is a golden rule: don't waste your own manpower doing this stuff, just punish other parties for not doing it. The responsibility is pushed lower down the system. Ian Johnson wrote about this in his Pulitzer-winning series. The end result is that the cop with the electric baton is going to get his pay docked if he doesn't get a "confession" from the helpless, middle-aged woman who practices Falun Gong. So he smashes her face in and kills her in pursuit of that. No one wants to lose a portion of their pay packet, but only under a uniquely grotesque set of circumstances will a man be driven to commit such evils to avoid it. Such is modern China.

More: 

The mechanisms to place greater responsibility at the local level include personalized, and in some cases, invasive measures that reach into the workplaces and homes of Falun Gong practitioners. For example, the May 5 Tianwen Town People's Government document calls on authorities to "mobilize and organize basic-level Party organizations and mass organizations, form responsibility help and education small groups, and enter the villages and homes [of Falun Gong practitioners] to conduct an educational assault." The April 6 Jiyuan Municipal Bureau of Industry and Information Technology document calls on local authorities to require local businesses to establish "transformation through reeducation assault work small groups" and develop an individual plan to "transform" each employee who has not been "transformed." The June 13 Jiangxi Provincial Reeducation Through Labor Administration Bureau document calls for people's police to improve their knowledge and studies of sociology, medicine, psychology, and religion as part of their "transformation through reeducation" work. 

The other valuable thing about these documents is that they directly implicate Party Central in the campaign. It's not that any more proof was needed, it's just important from the perspective of rock-solid evidence. The apparatchiks at the top never just "banned" Falun Gong and then some local roughs got a bit too excited. It's that the whole thing is driven from the top:

The documents indicate that the Party has taken a lead role in initiating and overseeing the 2010-2012 campaign. Three of the documents cite the 17th Party Congress as a basis for the campaign (Hepu County Water Bureau; CACA, 5 August 10; Longnan County Bureau of Industry and Information Technology), and the August 5 CACA document states specifically that the 17th Party Congress "put forward a new, higher requirement" in "the work of dealing with cults, including transformation through reeducation." 

There's a lot more there. Read the full release. In conclusion I reproduce their table but with the links swapped out for permanent ones, from webcitation.org. As flippant as the cadres appear to be about letting this news get out, they sometimes do take things down that have caught on in the media (though don't go holding your breath for the MSM to pick this story up). CECC uses the direct Party links. Below are permalinks for perpetual reference:

Source

Title

Date

China Anti-Cult Association

Suxian District, Chenzhou City, Hunan Province, Implements Shingle-Hanging Transformation as Shining Tactic in Three-Year Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle

6 August 10

 

China Anti-Cult Association

Prepare Basic Thinking on Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle

5 August 10

 

Longnan County Bureau of Industry and Information Technology, Ganzhou city, Jiangxi province; reprinted on Web site of the Longnan County People's Government

County Industry and Information Bureau Establishing, Synthesizing, and Maintaining Stability Work Summary for the First Half of 2010

30 June 10

 

Gulou District People's Government, Fuzhou city, Fujian province

Kaiyuan Community 2010-2012 Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle Work Implementation Plan

27 June 10

 

Jiangxi Provincial Reeducation Through Labor (RTL) Administration Bureau

Provincial RTL System Mobilization and Deployment Meeting on Transformation-Through-Reeducation "New Three-Year Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle" Convenes at Provincial Women's RTL Center

13 June 10

 

Tianwen Town People's Government, Weng'an county, Qiannan Buyi & Miao Autonomous Prefecture, Guizhou province; reprinted on Web site of Weng'an County People's Government

Tianwen Town 2010-2012 Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle Work Plan

5 May 10

 

General Office of the Ruichang Municipal People's Government, Jiujiang city, Jiangxi province; reprinted on Web site of the Ruichang Municipal People's Government

Hongxia Township 2010-2012 Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle Work Plan

26 April 10

 

Chengxi Town Party Committee, Guoyang county, Bozhou city, Anhui province; reprinted on Web site of Guoyang County People's Government

Chengxi Town 2010-2012 Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Plan

13 April 10

 

Binhu Township Party and Government General Office, Changji city, Changji Hui Autonomous Prefecture, Xingjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region; reprinted on Web site of the Changji Municipal People's Government

Notice Concerning Printing and Distributing the "Binhu Township 2010-2012 Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle Work Plan"

13 April 10

 

Jiyuan Municipal Bureau of Industry and Information Technology, Henan province; reprinted on Web site of the Jiyuan Municipal People's Government

Regarding Launching the 2010-2012 Jiyuan City Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle Work

6 April 10

 

Longbu Town Party Committee, Anyuan county, Pingxiang city, Jiangxi province; reprinted on the official Web site of the Anyuan County People’s Government

Notice Concerning Printing and Distributing the "Longbu Town 2010-2012 Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle Work Plan"

2 April 10

 

Hefei Daily, reprinted on the Web site of the Hefei Municipal People's Government, Anhui province

Yang Sisong Attends City-Wide Mobilization and Deployment Meeting on Work To Defend Against and Handle Cults and the Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle

1 April 10

 

General Office of the Ningdu County People's Government, Gansu prefecture, Jiangxi province; reprinted on Web site of the Ningdu County People's Government

Notice Concerning the "Ningdu County Sanitation System 2010-2012 Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle Work Plan"

18 March 10

Hepu County Water Bureau, Beihai city, Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region

Hepu County Water Bureau Party Committee's 2010-2012 Transformation-Through-Reeducation Assault and Consolidation Overall Battle Work Plan 

(Cached copy available via Google)

Undated

Their release on March 22 comes almost a year after the documents first surfaced. But better late than never. And the meticulous arrangement they have given the material more than makes up for the tardiness.

This entry was posted in miscellany. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to China’s Mass Brainwashing for the Modern Age

  1. Kim says:

    A pure waste of manpower, money and resources to "paddle a boat upstream" for the purpose of covering up history's worse human rights abuse and genocide for the sake of temporarily keeping a few criminals in power and covering up their crimes.  It is time for the beautiful people of China to wake up and free themselves of this silliness otherwise future generations of Chinese will ask "What have we done (or not done) to allow this kind of embarrassment to continue for the sake of what self-interest?"

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>