Good and Evil in China and the Contradictions of Xi Jinping

CHINA IS FULL of contradictions, isn't it? Here's a good one, revealed in two recent articles I read. 

The first is Reuters' excellent summary of Xi Jinping, his biography, his place in the Party, and his possible leadership trajectory (it primarily involves simply maintaining power and the interest cliques, apparently.)

But there are some incongruities, including a big one about what Xi believes vis-a-vis the role of morality in ordering life. 

We are told, both in the Reuters article and one run earlier by the New York Times that said many of the same things, that Xi appreciates movies that show a struggle between good and evil.

"Xi said he particularly likes Hollywood movies about World War II and hopes Hollywood will continue to make them," said a cable on that dinner. "Hollywood makes those moves well, and such Hollywood movies are grand and truthful," the notes on the meeting said.

"Americans have a clear outlook on values and clearly demarcate between good and evil," Xi told the ambassador's party. In contrast, Xi said he found some recent popular Chinese movies "confusing" and too focused on palace intrigues or vulgar kung fu. He chastised unnamed Chinese directors saying some of them "neglect values they should promote."

Anyone would ask whether the man was dissembling. The question of good and evil is indeed a key one for modern China. And here is a 'touch of evil' to present the contrast. 
 
It is from the other article I saw today, on the Falun Gong website Clearwisdom. I received the note in my email. The piece is a triumphant review of how a Falun Gong group ambushed, at a Taiwanese airport, with banners and slogans, a CCP official who involves himself in the torture and murder of people of that faith in China. But the good/evil point comes out toward the end. There is a table at the end of the article, a table of evil. It says things like:
 
 

Year/Month

Abuse and Torture Cases in Masanjia

1

2000/10 Labor camp authorities ordered 18 female Falun Gong practitioners to be stripped, then thrown in male cells. In the resulting cruel torture of the practitioners, at least five died, seven suffered a mental collapse, and many were injured. Ms. Sun Yan was stripped, beaten, shocked with electric batons, and tortured with chili pepper applied to her vagina, among other brutal, sexual assault.

2

2001/6 Ms. Zhao Suhuan was locked in solitary confinement, tortured, and brutally beaten. She was subjected to sleep deprivation and electric baton shocks.

3

2005/6 Ms. Gao Rongrong was shocked with electric batons on the face for seven hours by guards in Longshan Forced Labor Camp. She escaped with the help of fellow practitioners, and photos of her disfigured face were exposed overseas, causing great concern in the international community. Ms. Gao was later arrested again, secretly locked in Masanjia Forced Labor Camp, and tortured to death.

4

2006/5 Guard Ma Qishan and Camp Director Cao tortured Ms. Shi Guirong by hanging her up, tying her to a death bed and force-feeding her unknown drugs.

5

2008/5 Guards tortured Mr. Li Hailong with painful stretching. They also tortured Mr. Cai Chao with electric baton shocks his neck, hands, stomach and back. It took him more than one month to recover.

6

2008/6 Second Section warden You Ran of Masanjia Second Ward slammed Mr. Cui Guohua's head against the wall, severely injuring him. He was later beaten, shocked with electric batons, and hung up by handcuffs.

7

2008/6 Guards shocked Mr. Luo Chunzhong in his mouth for 30 minutes with electric batons, resulting in his mouth swelling severely and his teeth becoming loosened. He was then shocked for another two hours in other places on his body, and later forced to stand for an extended period of time.

8

2008/6 Five to six guards shocked Mr. Zheng Xujun with electric batons for more than one hour, then forced Mr. Zheng Xujun, Mr. Chen Yan, and Mr. Sun Shuchen to stand for one week. Mr. Sun Shuchen suffered a mental collapse after being electrically shocked. The guards also used high-voltage electric batons to shock Mr. Zheng Haitao, Mr. Zhao Jian, Mr. Cui Dejun, Mr. Du Zhiying, Mr. Zhao Liankai, and Mr. Liu Yu.

9

2008/6 Guards brutally beat Mr. Yu Ming, shocked him with electric batons, and hung him up by handcuffs for several days. They locked him in a metal cage for three months, in a position in which he could not stand up or lie down. They electric baton-shocked his penis, poured cold water onto him, then tied him up while continuing to abuse him sexually. This torture almost killed him.

10

2008/9 Female guards pried open Ms. Zhang Lianying's mouth to force-feed her, and hung her up for three whole days by handcuffs. They also shocked her with electric batons, forced her to stand a long time, and beat her with wooden sticks. Third Ward warden Zhang Zhuohui tortured Ms. Qiu Shuqin with hanging up and electric baton shocks, resulting in Ms. Qiu suffering a severe headache. She had to be rushed to the hospital. Guards also tortured Ms. Wu Juan, Ms. Zhang Yinying, Ms. Zhang Min, Ms. Jia Yahui with hanging up, and electric baton shocks over several days.

11

2009/10 First Ward warden Gao Hongchang and Third Section chiefs Jing Hongbo and Yu Jiang tortured Mr. Wang Haihui for 24 hours with electric baton shocks and stretching. During the day they hung him up or stretched him, and during the night, they handcuffed him on the “dead person's bed.”

12

2009/12 Mr. Sun Yi also was tortured with electric baton shocks and stretching, then forced to stand for two months. This torture caused his legs to swell and bleeding to occur under the skin. He became emaciated and extremely weak as a result of this torture.
 
 
I did not read every entry carefully. Each is traceable back to more minute reports on what precisely happened to those people. I am not sure of Mr. Xi's role in the persecution of Falun Gong in Fujian Province, where he was the Party man for close to two decades.
 
But the persecution of this group happens across China. It is evil. Mr. Xi will be taking over the leadership of the CCP, which is the prime mover in this most unprecedented exercise of evil. Does Mr. Xi really appreciate the difference between good and evil?
This entry was posted in human rights, the Party and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>